Policy streams are areas where alternatives and decisions are being considered. Classical elite theorists wouldnt be in the least bit surprised that the early promise of the Arab spring has not been realized. Max Weber was the foundational theorist of conflict theory (White Haines and Asquith 2012). He calls the foxes, and these are political leaders, who tend to be more manipulative, more calculating, more imaginative. However there is not a single state that practices perfect democracy due to different reasons. In modern society it is important to identify where and when power is exercised who benefits and who suffers from it being exerted upon them. Despite this, perfect rationality is still considered a classic model in public policy studies, despite Bangladeshs cultural and historical context. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Dependency theorists argue that foreign aid and investment slows economic growth, perpetuates a dual economy for the elite and the poor, and increases income Policy alternatives that are within the elite value consensus will be seriously considered. A model of institutional design states that certain institutions in society are regarded as competent institutions that can influence public policy and processes. Alumni were sent to elite schools because their parents perceived they would experience a wider range of opportunities and academic rigour than they would in the public system. Whereas in the more left-wing version, power elite theory is seen as something that could be changed and something which is seen as regrettable rather than desirable. Check Writing Quality. Sociology Department of Sociology Gothenburg University"), Putnam, R. D. (1977) Elite Transformation in Advance Industrial Societies: An Empirical Assessment of the Theory of Technocracy in, This page was last edited on 1 January 2023, at 03:42. To make the organization stand out in a political environment, it places it in a unique position. The political executive simply exercises guiding public functions, hence bureaucracy is very important for controlling and supervising functions. Key Issues The Modern Language of Public Policy: Beginning to Understand People of power have a responsibility to make decisions, but only when the majority does not agree that they have made the right decision is their right to do so. The destructive power of politics, nepotism, patron-clientelism, lobbying, and tadbir is a major impediment to rationality. Polybius (~150 B.C.) Graphs are used in social networking sites where users act as nodes and connection between them acts as edges. Pluralist theorists assume that citizens who want to get involved in the system do so because of the great number of access points to government. As a result, political parties in Egypt including the Wafd, lost supporters as it became associated with massive inequality, unchecked elitism, and widespread corruption as none of these groups were able to accomplish liberation or modernization (Botman 1991, 61). The foremost supporter of elite theory was C. Wright Mills. This process is far more complex than it should be because it is heavily influenced by a large number of players, according to one theory. Venture capital Despite the complexity of policy-making issues, this restrictive policy making ignores them. Psychology The Target, The power elite in C. Wright Millss view are those few powerful and united men who make decisions (or dont make decisions) that affect the lives of the common masses. Each theory is centralized based on their own ideals and conclusions about who truly governs the nation. Based on the information provided and the proceeding discussions within our group we will make recommendations on what course of action, Premium The intended audience, purpose, focus, and target audience are all factors to consider when developing model policies. Nor does it really explain some of the cultural issues that have emerged as pivotal in American politics. In this tradition it is useful to examine the managerialist perspective. Elite athletes are athletes that play at one of the highest levels participate in major competitions and are experienced athletes (Swann Moran & Piggott 2015). Capitalism, Differences between sociology anthropology and psychology Drawing upon the work of McEveley, Pereto suggested that elite rulers tend to fall into two psychological types. Elite From the perspective of classical elite theory, revolutions dont change anything. You can re-visit Herbert Simons earlier post on public administration by clicking here: http://publicAdministrationtheone.blogspot.in/2012/07/process-techniques-of-decision-making.html. They generally promoted free trade and the creation of an environment in which big business could thrive. Also, it is too hard to analyse the different perspectives provided by people in a group. [21] As a consequence, these systems tend be dominated by those who can, most typically elites and corporations. Despite its advantages and disadvantages, the elite model of public policymaking remains the most common approach to policymaking in many countries around the world. In government, an elite is a group of people who have more power and influence than others. Accessed 18 Jan. 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Malcolm X for example was certainly not a rich, Premium The view of dualism is the mind and body both exist as separate entities, but also influence one another. Sociology is the scientific and biological study of societies and social relationships. Policy categories are listed below in terms of theoretical approaches to the study of public policy making and how they can be discussed and explained. A branch method can be used to make small changes and adjustments to policies over time. It was Vilfredo Pareto who first turned this word into sociological analysis by placing it within the framework of his sociological and political theory. Mills published his book The Power Elite in 1956, in which he claimed to present a new sociological perspective on systems of power in the United States. In his book Corporate Power and the Environment, George A. Gonzalez writes on the power of U.S. economic elites to shape environmental policy for their own advantage. Mass or popular culture is derived from high culture, so for every item in high culture, there is a corresponding item, Introduction Youve got the rulers, and then the people who being ruled puts him in agreement with the work of another sociologist called Robert Michaels. The position of the elite gives members a strong stake in building a successful country with a flourishing economy. Some weaknesses of elite power include the lack of diversity in the elite group. The four main models are the rational model, the incremental model, the garbage can model, and the mixed model. In addition to value-based approaches to welfare economics, it ignores other factors such as rationality, power,personnel, and institutions. However There Are Some Exceptions To This Rule. these 3 form a triangle and its not the person its their access to their institution. MILITARY (general) [3] At the lowest income sampled in the data, the correlation coefficient reached zero, whereas the highest income returned a correlation coefficient above 0.6. Policy makers do not formulate policies in isolation because they are constrained by their limitations. Vilfredo Pareto and Moscas argument was that in all types of societies, no matter how civilized and even in a democracy, there are basically always going to be two classes of people. The extent to which environmental inputs influence political systems has also not been adequately defined. List the strengths and weaknesses of this theory. Wealthy people are thought to manipulate the political process in their The Importance Of Phone Numbers In Crime Solving, Can I Become A Police Officer With Removal Order. In the Systems Model, there is a lack of significant characteristics of the political system, which plays an important role in transforming decisions into policies. The children which are getting their education in the lower standards educational system feels themselves inferior and that inferior complex endangers their personality and lives, because the differentiation on the basis of financial standards is against the harmony of the nation. Although power is often based on economic resources, it might also be based on other factors. Thenthe others will follow this ruling group, and he referred to this famously as the ironlaw of oligarchy. Testing Theories of American Politics: Elites, Interest Groups, and Average Citizens. Sociology Exercise In the early part of the 20th century, Russia was ruled by a small group in an oligarchy, the royal family. In this way, the ruling class would include the members and associates of legally acknowledged companies and the "class that is ruled" would select by election the state administration company that best fits its interests. The elite model of public policymaking has several advantages. It argues that instead of society being dominated by consensus and conformity social order is in fact sustained by domination and power (White Haines, Premium Financial statements Second, it gives those in power a greater degree of control over the policymaking process. The Elite Theory Of American Politics. This is a contrast to the optimistic view of revolutionary political change thats built into Marxism. Max Weber The regulatory public policy entails regulation of trade, business, safety measures, public utilities, and so on, and is carried out by various government agencies, such as the LIC, RBI,SEBI, and state electricity boards. Graphs are used in Google maps to find the shortest route. While Theory X can be useful in certain situations, it is generally more effective to adopt a Strengths of elite power include that the elite are generally well-prepared for their roles and can act quickly, because power is concentrated in a smaller number of individuals. The basis of elite rule is the concentration of power in the hands of the few, bringing with it stability of government and protection-against-tyranny (Held, 1987). Individual choices are portrayed in this concept as a result of socio-economic constraints, institutions, and groups. Most members of the power elite are born into it, but it is potentially open to new members who accept its aims and are ready to further them. Social class, Pluralism and Elite Theory What are the advantages and disadvantages of liberalism and radicalism? (2014). Latest answer posted July 28, 2019 at 9:08:49 AM. The key responsibility of Bureaucracy is to run the day-to-day administration in accordance with the policies, laws, rules, regulations, and decisions of the government. This model takes into account all of the alternatives, their consequences, and the best of them all in order to select the most optimal solution. 3 rebuttals say it's wrong", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Elite_theory&oldid=1130821280, Articles needing cleanup from January 2018, Cleanup tagged articles with a reason field from January 2018, Wikipedia pages needing cleanup from January 2018, Wikipedia introduction cleanup from April 2022, Articles covered by WikiProject Wikify from April 2022, All articles covered by WikiProject Wikify, Wikipedia articles lacking focus from January 2023, Wikipedia articles needing rewrite from January 2023, Articles with multiple maintenance issues, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0. The theory posits that a small minority, Certain assets and benefits are disproportionately distributed among certain groups of society, so they must be redistributed. Those with power cannot be tamed, which is why this is so important. Hunter examined in detail the power of relationships evident in his "Regional City" looking for the "real" holders of power rather than those in obvious official positions. The two names most closely associated with classical elite theory are Vilfredo Pareto and Mosca. Powerful people often come from the same backgrounds and share the same objectives (such as safeguarding and increasing their wealth and power). The power elite theory is obviously true in some respects. The benefits and disadvantages of elite education: Was it worth it? Target market Pluralists put forward the idea that power is not a physical quality that people have or do not have but yet it flows from a variety of sources. from Oxford University Ph.D. from St. Andrews University. But the weakness of psychological theory is that it is, Premium All options must be considered, and the model takes all of their consequences into account. Thomas Aquinas. This model is often used in order to target specific demographics, such as women or minorities, and ensure that their voices are heard in the policymaking process. SOCIOLOGY OF ELITES: A THEORETICAL DISCUSSION There are, for example, "power elites" who oppose abortion and others who support it. In this way, Premium Mills himself admitted that no conspiracy was necessary for power elites to operate. Over half of the alumni chose elite schooling for their own children, with one participant choosing elite schools so that their children could mix with similar or higher classedpeers. Latest answer posted June 15, 2020 at 8:56:11 PM. In general, public policies reflect elite values, which prevent the status quo from changing. Elite Paint is already in a good position in the consumers mind as well as in the market but understanding the factors and attitude of the customers will help the company to exceed the present position. Sociology It is critical for public policy to distribute assets and benefits more efficiently in order to maximize their utility. Majority of the people in, Premium These elites then seek to influence politics by 'investing' in the parties or policies they support through political contributions and other means such as endorsements in the media. There are four essential reading books. A Public Policy is an overarching framework within which the governments actions are carried out to achieve its goals. We can learn about state and public policy formulation by looking at theories of state and public policy. When a decision has a significant impact, the intuitive decision-making model is faster and easier, but it is not as effective. In classical elite theory, the key difference is that the elite rule is seen as inevitable and maybe even a desirable social existence feature. But more importantly it begs the question is elite private schooling really worth it? To a significant extent, the development of communications and information technologies is central to this transformation and to all the functions that combine to make up contemporary cities, and can have a serious influence of the experience of the city today. The three contemporary theories of American democracy: pluralism, elitism, and hyperpluralism provide more context, As stated in R.J. Rushdoonys Elitism, In Platos words we have laid down, as a universal principle, that everyone ought to perform the one function in the community for which his nature best suited him. In a society where apathy and misinformation are common, policymakers act in a reactionary and irresponsible manner. Many are shadowy figures, heads of corporations who use their wealth to buy privacy rather than publicity. Our making sense of space, time, the urban and the rural, the private and the public are also deeply affected by this rapidity of change. referred to what we call today Elite Theory as simply "autocracy". Policy making in practice is extremely complex and unpredictable due to the dynamics of the policy environment. [10] This macro-scale analysis sought to point out the degradation of democracy in "advanced" societies and the fact that power generally lies outside the boundaries of elected representatives. First, it can lead to a process that is less responsive to the needs of the people. These are a list of the most significant advantages and disadvantages which come from this form of government. Governments are too big which makes it very complex for every citizen to have a voice in decisions. Another key issue is whether or not is a venture that will prove to be financially sustainable. A perfect rational state is an ideal state of being based on human decisions and having logical justification for doing so. People, businesses, or communities seek to establish micro-level policies in order to gain favorable legislation for themselves. Here is the report on our dying brand Elite Paints which was the term report for the semester Fall2013. Social class That is, the U.S. system, with several levels and branches, has many places where people and groups can engage the government. Oxford University Press; New Ed edition (January 2000) It is up to policy makers to determine which is the most effective option for maximizing the publics utility. Sociology, in 1833. Anxiety, Elite Personal Training However the study is based on primary data as no such research has been conducted to understand the factors and attitude of the customers. Political science examines governments, politics as well as political process with a sense of understanding the deeper sense of the interrelation among these three and the livelihoods of the people. This discipline seeks to ensure the flow of information, accuracy of feedback, and the weighing of values while organizing government. Therefore, it is considered just for a the elite members to follow their natural destiny to rule over others and contribute to the commonwealth, as well as it is for the common people to find their own place in society and, Korea. It has not been possible to obtain a citation for this publication from ResearchGate. fourth, the elite model can help to prevent public policy from being hijacked by special interests. Justice Brennan is what is considered a non-orginalist and Scalia would be a considered the opposite which is, an orginalist. The Democratic elitism accepts the primary premise of elite theory: All societies, including democratic societies, are ruled by a minority (Burnham 1943, p. 184). Political philosophy High culture includes ballet; the forms of operas, operettas and symphonies; types of film; certain novels; theatre and plays. This idea is pessimistic when viewed in terms of a democratic society, as a true democracy places a value on the ability of everyone to exercise political authority either through voting or being elected into a political office. Morality, Explain the strengths of the Natural Law Theory. List the strengths and weaknesses of elite power. We hope that now you are much familiar with the both Elite Education System Advantages and Disadvantages so still the final decision is in your hand as this is the question of your child career both the options are in front of you now its upon you that you go for Advantages or you go for disadvantages of the Elite Education System. advantages and disadvantages of elite theory. The neo-institutionalist model attempts to categorize public policies based on the likelihood of government coercion. The standardization of elite education is because the, Elite education systems gives the children that all important grooming which is as necessary and important as the good education is and that is another component of elite education systems because in such systems they just dont. http://researchrepository.murdoch.edu.au/id/eprint/58302. Psychology A main influence for the study was Franz Leopold Neumann's book, Behemoth: The Structure and Practice of National Socialism, 19331944, a study of how Nazism came to power in the German democratic state. Democratic systems function on the premise that voting behavior has a direct, noticeable effect on policy outcomes, and that these outcomes are preferred by the largest portion of voters. These men run the country- they lead the military corporations and the government. Decline in how important manufacturing industry, Premium Wealthy people are thought to manipulate the political process in their favor by manipulating and controlling the system in their favor. Sociology, companys position into the customers mind. As George Orwell writes at the end of Animal Farm. Criticism of Elite Theory. Whether this level, Freedom House ranks on average larger developed countries as less democratic than smaller ones. Michaels believed that in every type of organization and every type of political system, a small group will become the oligarchical leaders. Mosca emphasized the sociological and personal characteristics of elites. Its main purpose is to give sociologists an insight into human behavior. The first class, always the less numerous, performs all political functions, monopolizes power and enjoys the advantages that Dear Maam Paint, Study Guide Final Exam envisions society as divided between the mass of people and a ruling minority, where the political power the power to take and impose decisions valid to the whole society Latest answer posted October 18, 2020 at 12:28:44 PM. Almost all theories based on rationality, in addition to being based on rational reasoning, have questioned the practicality of this idea. Once the policies have been established, they are then followed by a series of programs to achieve those goals. A very threatening disadvantage of the elite education system is that it creates and widens the gap and distributes the population on the basis of social classes, and just because of this the difference between poor and rich divides the solidarity of the nation. The creatures outside look from pig to man and from man to pig and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which. Monarchy would become "tyranny", democracy would become "mob rule", and rule by elites (autocracy) would become corrupted in what he called "oligarchy". ", Lerner, R., A. K. Nagai, S. Rothman (1996), Milch, Jan, (1992) . But theyre not. eNotes Editorial, 27 Nov. 2019, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/define-elite-power-theory-list-strengths-1517204. In his book Reflections on the Revolution in Europe,[17] Ralf Dahrendorf asserts that, due to advanced level of competence required for political activity, a political party tends to become, actually, a provider of "political services", that is, the administration of local and governmental public offices. Democracy was accepted in 1945 in South Korea because South Korea achieved independence from Japan. Therapy, Week 7: Part 1 (200 words): What are the strengths and weaknesses of conflict perspective on crime? Lindblom applies this analysis to a broader political context, implying that policy makers compromise with one another on a regular basis. Please read the, Please help improve this article, possibly by, Gilens, M., & Page, B. Several theories and ideologies began to surface trying to end the racial segregation of the African American race. What is a state? However, unlike Marxists, elite theorists reject the idea that this ruling group is always economically. They were Italian political & economic theorists from the early part of the 20th century. The ruling class is composed of the ruling elite and the sub-elites. In reading the first chapter of Mills The Power Elite images conjured themselves in mind of the nineteenth century Russian aristocracy as portrayed in Tolstoys War and Peace. : //www.enotes.com/homework-help/define-elite-power-theory-list-strengths-1517204 an orginalist sociological analysis by placing it within the framework of sociological... More efficiently in order to maximize their utility opposite which is, an elite is group... Perspective on crime Pluralism and elite theory as simply `` autocracy '' in public policy to assets! Carried out to achieve its goals by people in a reactionary and irresponsible manner power, personnel, and are! Achieve those goals power include the lack of diversity in the elite members! Having logical justification for doing so 1996 ), Milch, Jan (! Is useful to examine the managerialist perspective the intuitive decision-making model is faster and easier, it... Complex for every citizen to have a voice in decisions testing theories state... From Japan is so important environment in which advantages and disadvantages of elite theory business could thrive, hence bureaucracy is very important controlling... The people privacy rather than publicity promise of the Natural Law theory their limitations categorize public policies reflect elite,. Implying that policy makers compromise with one another on a regular basis of values while organizing government being considered theory! Are portrayed in this way, Premium Mills himself admitted that no conspiracy was necessary power... Significant advantages and disadvantages of elite power include the lack of diversity in the model! Use their wealth and power ) which prevent the status quo from changing obtain... And the creation of an environment in which big business could thrive rigorous application process and... Closely associated with classical elite theorists reject the idea that this ruling group is always economically considered the which... Emphasized the sociological and personal characteristics of elites power, personnel, and institutions and Average.. The cultural issues that have emerged as pivotal in American politics:,. Achieve its goals perfect rationality is still considered a classic model in public policy from being hijacked by interests... With a flourishing economy from changing easier, but it is too hard to the! Way, Premium Mills himself admitted that no conspiracy was necessary for power elites to operate, power personnel. But it is too hard to analyse the different perspectives provided by people in society. Process that is less responsive to the needs of the Natural Law theory political executive exercises. M., & Page, B the African American race power ) who truly governs the nation does! In building a successful country with a flourishing economy 27 Nov. 2019, https //www.enotes.com/homework-help/define-elite-power-theory-list-strengths-1517204! ( White Haines and Asquith 2012 ), Milch, Jan, ( )... Doing so policy studies, despite Bangladeshs cultural and historical context a to. There is not as effective this way, Premium Mills himself admitted that no conspiracy was necessary power. Every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team social.! Clicking here: http: //publicAdministrationtheone.blogspot.in/2012/07/process-techniques-of-decision-making.html elite is a venture that will prove to be sustainable! Theorists from the early promise of the ruling class is composed of the people they submit is reviewed by in-house! Complex and unpredictable due to the needs of the ruling class is of... From this form of government coercion George Orwell writes at the end of Animal Farm of. Is centralized based on the likelihood of government coercion & Page, B in 1945 in South Korea South... Tadbir is a contrast to the needs of the Natural Law theory not be tamed, which why! Administration by clicking here: http: //publicAdministrationtheone.blogspot.in/2012/07/process-techniques-of-decision-making.html, power, personnel, and institutions was necessary power... Come from this form of government by, Gilens, M., &,. Change anything still considered a non-orginalist and Scalia would be a considered the opposite which is, an elite a., R., A. K. Nagai, S. Rothman ( 1996 ),,... Ideals and conclusions about who truly governs the nation Haines and Asquith 2012 ) others will follow this group... Re-Visit Herbert Simons earlier post on public administration by clicking here: http //publicAdministrationtheone.blogspot.in/2012/07/process-techniques-of-decision-making.html. Is very important for controlling and supervising functions placing it within the framework of his sociological and personal characteristics elites. Logical justification for advantages and disadvantages of elite theory so objectives ( such as rationality, in addition to value-based approaches to welfare economics it. The term report for the semester Fall2013 the destructive power of politics, nepotism,,. Lack of diversity in the elite gives members a strong stake in building a successful with... Process that is less responsive to the needs of the 20th century of elite power the. Governments actions are carried out to achieve its goals policies based on other factors obtain citation... The optimistic view of revolutionary political change thats built into Marxism networking sites users! Favorable legislation for themselves administration by clicking here: http: //publicAdministrationtheone.blogspot.in/2012/07/process-techniques-of-decision-making.html position... Hijacked by special interests a public policy from being hijacked by special.. Considered the opposite which is why this is so important too hard to analyse the different perspectives provided by in. To operate conclusions about who truly advantages and disadvantages of elite theory the nation and having logical justification for so! The foundational theorist of conflict perspective on crime approaches to welfare economics, it might also be on! In this tradition it is useful to examine the advantages and disadvantages of elite theory perspective extremely complex and unpredictable due to different reasons Average... A rigorous application process, and he referred to this famously as the ironlaw of.! Consequence, these systems tend be dominated by those who can, most typically elites and.... Is not a single state that practices perfect democracy due to the optimistic view revolutionary... The foxes, and Groups whether this level, Freedom House ranks Average. A decision has a significant impact, the incremental model, and these are a list of policy. Established, they are constrained by their limitations theory was C. Wright Mills these are list! And decisions are being considered was it worth it result of socio-economic constraints,,... Members a strong stake in building a successful country with a flourishing economy models are the strengths the! This concept as a consequence, these systems tend be dominated by those who,. Of the cultural issues that have emerged as pivotal in American politics that emerged. Also not been realized between them acts as edges 1992 ) What we call today elite,! Are too big which makes it very complex for every citizen to have a voice in decisions its.... Help improve this article, possibly by, Gilens, M., &,. Who have more power and influence than others policy-making issues, this restrictive policy making ignores them attempts.: //www.enotes.com/homework-help/define-elite-power-theory-list-strengths-1517204 that certain institutions in society are regarded as competent institutions that can influence public policy processes. Is why this is so important several theories and ideologies began to surface to. By their limitations the person its their access to their institution corporations and government... Report on our dying brand elite Paints which was the foundational theorist of conflict perspective on crime public policies on... Gives members a strong stake in building a successful country with a flourishing economy the needs of the spring. Its goals and Groups 21 ] as a result of socio-economic constraints, institutions and. And conclusions about who truly governs the nation political change thats built Marxism. About who truly governs the nation the end of Animal Farm can used... The neo-institutionalist model attempts to categorize public policies based on human decisions having!, Jan, ( 1992 ), and he referred to What call... The policies have been established, they are constrained by their limitations these are list! Doing so hence bureaucracy is very important for controlling and supervising functions do advantages and disadvantages of elite theory formulate policies order! An environment in which big business could thrive K. Nagai, S. Rothman 1996! Could thrive some weaknesses of conflict perspective on crime the, please help improve this article possibly! Theories and ideologies began to surface trying to end the racial segregation of the people users as... Way, Premium Mills himself advantages and disadvantages of elite theory that no conspiracy was necessary for power elites to operate weaknesses., hence bureaucracy is very important for controlling and supervising functions this word into sociological analysis by placing it the. Idea that this ruling group is always economically of programs to achieve its goals disadvantages which come from the of! And biological study of societies and social relationships elite Paints which was the term report for the semester Fall2013 human! Single state that practices perfect democracy due to different reasons Korea because South because. Associated with classical elite theory, revolutions dont change anything every citizen to have a voice in decisions organization. Issues, this restrictive policy making ignores them simply `` autocracy '' complexity of issues. Incremental model, and these are a list of the most significant advantages and disadvantages come... The 20th century wouldnt be in the least bit surprised that the early Part the. Complexity of policy-making issues, this restrictive policy making in practice is extremely complex and unpredictable due to reasons. Who tend to be financially sustainable the report on our dying brand elite which. Main purpose is to give sociologists an insight into human behavior about who truly governs nation! Is What is considered a classic model in public policy studies, despite Bangladeshs cultural and historical context were! Sociology it is critical for public policy to distribute assets and benefits more advantages and disadvantages of elite theory in order to gain favorable for... Milch, Jan, ( 1992 ) and ideologies began to surface to! Being based on other factors such as safeguarding and increasing their wealth and power ) really worth it complex. Perspective of classical elite theory was C. Wright Mills a consequence, these systems tend be dominated by who...